What Happened: By the 12-mile mark, McClain had built a 50-meter lead over Hurley and Kurgat. McClain appeared comfortably on pace for her second national title. But as the course approached a pedestrian bridge at the intersection of Nelson Street and Ted Turner Drive, the lead vehicle turned left past a set of cones and off the official course. McClain followed instinctively, with Hurley, Kurgat, and Carrie Ellwood all doing the same. (Ellwood corrected her mistake in time to turn back and take second in the race.) The rest of the pack continued straight on the correct route.

We have shared a video on Twitter and Instagram showing the intersection where the mistake was made.

McClain ran in the wrong direction for over a minute before an official signaled the mistake. The leaders turned back, but the damage was done. The detour cost the top three well over two minutes.

Update: Two hours after the publication of this article, the Atlanta Track Club shared more details on the events that transpired on Sunday morning and how an on-duty officer being struck by a car triggered a cascade of events that left a critical intersection unguarded at precisely the wrong moment.

Here’s what happened, according to the Atlanta Track Club’s latest statement:

8:05 AM – A Fulton County Sheriff’s officer working the race was struck by a vehicle at Mitchell & Ted Turner Drive, which is roughly 300 feet from the critical Nelson Street intersection.

8:07 AM – “Officer down” broadcast goes out. Race-assigned officers at Nelson Street immediately leave their post to respond, before repositioning traffic cones.

8:10 AM – The lead men’s athletes successfully navigate the intersection, still guided by race motorcycles.

8:15 AM – An off-duty (non-race) officer fills in at Nelson Street, focused on managing emergency vehicles and unaware that a footbridge ahead was part of the race route.

8:20 AM – The lead women’s pack arrives. The pace vehicle driver, seeing no cones and a police motorcycle ahead, follows it...turning left instead of continuing straight onto the footbridge.

8:21 AM – 25 seconds later, a race-assigned officer returns and catches the four women. They turn around and rejoin the course at the same point they exited.

You can find the entire timeline from the Atlanta Track Club here.

The result: Molly Born, running in fifth at the time of the wrong turn, stayed on course and crossed the finish line first in 69:43. This marked a personal best and her second U.S. title in three months after her victory at the California International Marathon in December. Ellwood, finished second in 69:47. Annie Rodenfels came in third in 70:12 in her half marathon debut.

McClain ended up ninth in 71:27. Hurley finished 12th in 71:38. Kurgat was 13th in 71:50.

If you watch the replay of the race, you’ll catch McClain saying "I'm pissed" as she crossed the finish line. She has endured a string of near-misses in recent years after finishing fourth at both the 2024 U.S. Olympic Marathon Trials and the 10,000m on the track, as well as narrowly missing the team for the 2025 World Road Running Championships (4th in Atlanta last year) before that event was cancelled. Sunday's race appeared to finally be her moment before it unraveled in the most unfortunate of circumstances.

Born later told Race Results Weekly’s David Monti, “I shouldn't go to Copenhagen…I shouldn't. I'm fine. I'm not going to fight for my spot."

What was at stake: There was good prize money — $20,000 for first place, $12,000 for second, and $7,500 for third.

Update: From the latest statement: “Atlanta Track Club’s position remains unchanged: We are responsible for the integrity of these championships. We regret that Jess McClain, Emma Grace Hurley and Ednah Kurgat were impacted by this incident and were unable to be recognized as the top three finishers reflective of their performance on the course.”

The Atlanta Track Club is now matching prize money to correct the outcome.

McClain will receive the $20,000 first-place prize money. Hurley and Kurgat will split the combined second- ($12,000) and third-place ($7,500) prize money, as they were side-by-side when they went off course.

However, this race also served as the selection event for the 2026 World Athletics Road Running Championships in Copenhagen in September. So the wrong turn didn't just cost the leaders prize money; it potentially cost them spots on Team USA.

Under USATF's selection criteria, the top three finishers earn automatic berths. Those spots currently go to Born, Ellwood, and Rodenfels. A fourth member of the team is determined based off World Rankings.

McClain, Hurley, and Kurgat all filed appeals immediately after the race.

The ruling: USATF's jury of appeals acknowledged that the course violated Rule 243, which requires courses to be "adequately marked at strategic points to keep competitors on course," and that the inadequate markings "contributed to the misdirection." However, the jury said it found "no recourse within the USATF rulebook to alter the results order of finish," leaving the official standings unchanged. USATF also noted that lead vehicles are the responsibility of the local organizing committee — in this case, the Atlanta Track Club — under Rule 243.2.c.

Here is USATF’s full statement:

“Following the completion of the USATF Half Marathon Championship in Atlanta, a protest was filed by athletes in the women’s field who followed a lead vehicle off course. That protest was denied and an appeal was submitted. The jury of appeals found that "the event did not meet USATF Rule 243 and that the course was not adequately marked at the point of misdirection. This violation contributed to the misdirection taken by the athletes within the top four at the time of misdirection.

However, the jury of appeals finds no recourse within the USATF rulebook to alter the results order of finish. The results order of finish as posted is considered final." This race was a selection event for the 2026 World Road Running Championships. That team is not officially selected until May. USATF will review the events from Atlanta carefully. While we understand athletes are eager to resolve this issue expeditiously, our process will ensure an ultimate decision is in the best interest of all the athletes involved.

Lead vehicles are provided and managed by the local organizing committee as per Rule 243.2.c of the 2026 USATF Competition Rules. Any questions pertaining to the course and the vehicle should be directed to the local organizing committee, Atlanta Track Club.”

Responsibility and fallout: Atlanta Track Club CEO Rich Kenah issued a statement taking full responsibility, saying "athletes should never have to make a split-second decision between following a pace vehicle or trusting the official course," and pledging to make the affected athletes "whole."

Here is Kenah’s full statement:

“We were honored to host the USATF Half Marathon Championships for the second consecutive year as part of Atlanta Marathon Weekend. The athletes delivered championship-level performances worthy of a national stage and the men's race delivered an exciting result. In the women's race, a pace vehicle left the official course during Mile 11.

As Race Director, I take full responsibility for what occurred. Athletes should never have to make a split-second decision between following a pace vehicle or trusting the official course. We are conducting a full review to determine exactly how and why the vehicle left the course to strengthen safeguards moving forward. Atlanta Track Club will make best efforts to ensure the affected athletes — Jess McClain, Emma Grace Hurley and Ednah Kurgat — are made whole. We regret the confusion to the athletes affected on what was otherwise a banner day for road racing in the United States.”

What's next: USATF emphasized that the World Championship roster is not finalized until May and pledged to "review the events from Atlanta carefully." USATF issued another statement on Monday, after the story started getting picked up by broader sports media, saying: “USA Track & Field continues to carefully review the incident that occurred at the USATF Half Marathon Championships and resulted in the misdirection of three athletes. We understand this is a difficult and frustrating time for athletes. This matter is a top priority for our staff and volunteer committees. We are working to provide updates as quickly as we can as we explore options that not only align with USATF rules and policies but also provide fair outcomes for all the athletes impacted. Thank you for your patience and understanding.”

Some have called on USATF to use its broad discretionary authority, which includes a clause in its selection criteria acknowledging "unforeseen, intervening circumstances" to place McClain, Hurley, and Kurgat on the team regardless of their official finish positions. Ultimately, it’s not that simple.

Breaking Down The Selection Policy And Why There’s No Clean Fix

The rules, in plain English: USATF's selection criteria work in a specific order. First, the top three finishers at the USATF Half Marathon Championship race get automatic spots. If any of them decline, the spot gets offered down the finishing order but only to athletes who finished in the top five. After that, any remaining spots are filled by world ranking (in the Women’s Road Running Half Marathon - 10km category) as of May 5, 2026.

The problem: McClain, Hurley, and Kurgat finished 9th, 12th, and 13th — well outside the top 5. So under the written rules, there's no direct mechanism to hand them spots, even if everyone agrees they deserve them.

The "everyone declines" scenario — and why it gets messy:

Here's the path some are hoping for:

1. Born, Ellwood, and Rodenfels (the official top three) all decline their spots
2. Since no one else in the top five accepts either, all three spots fall to the world rankings list as of May 5th, 2026. It takes until May 5th for the rankings window to even close, meaning this won't be resolved quickly.
3. Athletes ranked above McClain, Hurley, and Kurgat on that list also voluntarily decline.
4. The three impacted women finally get their spots.

It could work, but it requires a remarkable chain of voluntary cooperation from multiple athletes, and it doesn't resolve cleanly.

Specifically, with regard to the fourth spot: USATF can send four athletes to Worlds. Once everyone above these three has declined, that fourth spot goes to whoever is next in the rankings after them, which means someone who had nothing to do with Atlanta still ends up potentially displaced.

No take-backs: If we’re reading the policy correctly, once a ranked athlete declines their spot to help McClain, Hurley, and Kurgat, USATF can't re-offer it to them. That athlete's spot is simply gone.

One example Preet Majithia and I floated on the CITIUS MAG Podcast is the fact that American record holder Weini Kelati is the top-ranked American right now after lowering her record to 1:06:04 in Barcelona. If it were up to us, and she had a desire to run at the World Road Running Championships (maybe in the lead-up to a marathon debut in the fall), she could take the first of the four World Rankings spots. Kelati did not race in Atlanta.

The World Rankings are slated to be updated next Tuesday. But here’s where things currently stand for the Americans:

– Emma Grace Hurley currently sits at No. 3 in the U.S. rankings – behind Kelati (1223 score) and Taylor Roe (1220). Hurley’s ranking did not change with Sunday’s result.

– McClain is seventh (1172). Her ranking did not change with Sunday’s result.

– Kurgat has yet to enter the rankings since she has not registered a third result over 10K, 15K, 10 Miles, 20K or the half marathon. Kurgat has run 1:05:46 (1139 points) for second at the 2025 USATF 20K Championships and now 1:11:50 for 13th place (1092 points) at the 2026 USATF Half Marathon Championships. Her coach, Scott Simmons, told CITIUS MAG that she is planning to race The Ten on the track on March 28th, the USATF 10 Mile Championships at the Credit Union Cherry Blossom 10 Mile on April 12th, and the NYRR Mini 10K on June 6th. They are also looking at other half marathon options.

A legal/ethical bind: Reversing the official results or bypassing the selection criteria (even for the right reasons) could expose USATF to legal challenges from Born, Ellwood, and Rodenfels, who ran the correct course and finished where they finished. The selection process was established in advance, and those athletes have rights tied to it, too. Now, it should be noted that it certainly sounds from their agents and their own respective posts on Instagram that they’re not threatening to do so.

Here is what each of the athletes who finished ahead of McClain, Hurley and Kurgat has said since:

1st place, Molly Born (via Instagram): I want everyone to know that I do not feel like the winner of the 2026 USATF Half Marathon Championships, because I know I should not actually be the winner. During the race, I did not see the top 3 ladies make the wrong turn, and thus had no idea I was technically in the lead after the fatefully confusing intersection with about a mile to go. After finishing, race officials were the ones to inform me about the situation and that I had actually “won” the race. Everyone can recognize that this is an unprecedented situation that must be treated differently than what @usatf rules may dictate. The least that can be done is to have the women who almost certainly would have finished top 3 (@jesstonn @ednah_kurgat @emmagracehurley ) represent the USA at worlds and compensate them monetarily. (@carrie.ellwoody was also ahead of me before taking the wrong turn as well) If a spot on the world team for Copenhagen is offered to me, I do not plan to take it regardless of who it goes to because I did not fairly earn it. Here’s to hoping there can be changes to the rules in this exceptional circumstance so that there may be some justice for the runners who were wronged.

2nd place, Carrie Ellwood (read the full post via Instagram): “...Walking away sad and frustrated at how the morning played out for the women ahead of me who rightfully deserved a spot on the podium and all the joy that comes with that (@jesstonn @emmagracehurley @ednah_kurgat). We all recognize what should be done and hope that you 3 are recognized as the true champions and get to rightfully represent team USA.”

3rd place, Annie Rodenfels (read the full post via Instagram: “...I hope USATF can make the fair decision in this case and announce @jesstonn @emmagracehurley and @ednah_kurgat as the official team for Copenhagen. While making a team is, of course, one of my main personal goals I feel strongly that I want to earn it fair and square and this simply doesn’t feel like that.”

(Note: Ellwood and Rodenfels’s agent, Josh Cox, also reiterated that they would pass on their spots for Worlds for McClain, Hurley, and Kurgat.)

4th place, Kassie Parker: Her team, Crown Running, posted recap that noted, “Kassie described the day best: ‘bittersweet chaos.’ Bittersweet because she raced with courage and composure, but unable to truly celebrate her accomplishment. Chaos because of the unfortunate situation where the top three athletes, who had pulled away, went off course.”

5th place, Anna Kostarellis: No social media posts or statements found.

6th place, Biruktayit Degefa: No social media posts or statements found.

7th place, Erika Kemp (read the full post via Instagram: “...One to remember but not in a good way. It's a messy situation and hopefully those with the power to somehow make it right will double down and do it. All we know for sure right now is that athletes who ran incredible races were denied their podium moment due to circumstances outside of their control and we can empathize with their frustration and disappointment. And the secondary top 3 that is currently the official top 3 also ran great races and again due to a situation unbeknownst to them have found themselves on top of that podium. Running is such a simple sport and you love to see hard work and quality racing from athletes get the results they've earned but some weird s**t happened and here we are.”

8th place, Allie Ostrander (read the full post via Instagram): “The athletes who ran amazing and placed top 3 didn’t get to enjoy it. The athletes who had a world team in their grasp had it stripped away. It was a mess in so many ways, and @usatf has refused to take accountability or do anything to rectify the situation.”

Final thoughts:

Chris Chavez: It seems like everyone knows what the right outcome is: Putting McClain, Hurley, and Kurgat on the team for the World Road Running Championships. Getting there through the existing rulebook, however, is less like flipping a switch and more like untangling a spiderweb with athletes caught in the middle of a mess they didn't create.

The rest is extra: Compensation, where possible, matters because brands oftentimes offer bonuses for podium finishes, selection bonuses for World Championship berths. I think all of it might be honored by certain brands regardless of the technical outcome.

The broader lesson here is tougher to process. Governing bodies write their policies to be airtight. Sadly, right now, it feels like the athletes pay the price when reality refuses to fit inside that. The Ted Stevens Act was designed to protect athletes from arbitrary selection decisions, which is a genuinely important function. But the rulebook maybe doesn’t anticipate these wild mistakes and failures.

With all of the online discourse around this, It is important to remember that there is a real difference between holding people accountable and just reacting. A lot of what's being floated right now (Threads is a hell hole for insufferable opinions) feels satisfying in the moment but falls apart the second you think through what it would actually mean in practice for the future.

Preet Majithia: The policies exist, in part, because subjectivity in selection is a door to chaos… and to lawsuits. This case, however, was not close. McClain, Hurley, and Kurgat were so far ahead that there was little doubt of the likely result. And yet USATF’s official statement (most likely drafted with the unmistakable hand of legal counsel) offered nothing in the way of human acknowledgment. The Atlanta Track Club, to its credit, said the athletes needed to be “made whole.” USATF said considerably less. What it couldn’t bring itself to write, apparently, was that these women had been wronged.

The legal caution is understandable because any admission of culpability opens a door that lawyers prefer to keep shut. But there is a meaningful difference between legal restraint and institutional coldness, and USATF landed on the wrong side of it. You can acknowledge that athletes were “unfortunately affected” without conceding liability. You can say you’re committed to finding resolution without guaranteeing one. Empathy, unlike selection criteria, does not need to survive an arbitration hearing.

However, imagine a situation where five athletes had broken away so it would be uncertain who would have ended up in those top three spots, or if the chase pack was much closer to that top three before they went off course. The route to a ‘fix’ would be far more complex and difficult in those scenarios, so USATF and those involved in organising road races more generally may be reticent to set a precedent in this specific scenario which could be much more difficult to apply if such a situation were to occur in another race.

Lastly, it seems like all the American women involved know each other, respect each other, and some are friends. Again, to why rules exist: If it were an international field, where there weren't those kinds of relationships (or if it was life-changing amounts of money on the line for some of the athletes), it would also be even more difficult to 'correct.'

Keep up with all things track and field by following us across Instagram, X, Threads, and YouTube. Catch the latest episodes of the CITIUS MAG Podcast on Spotify and Apple Podcasts. For more, subscribe to The Lap Count and CITIUS MAG Newsletter for the top running news delivered straight to your inbox.